All-Star One-Time Champs Since 2000 in College Wrestling Posted April 9 · Report reply 4 hours ago, Perry said: 149 is brutal but I think I would take Caldwell at his peak. His domination of metcalf still sticks with me. Big fan of the askren pick as well If by 'at his peak' you mean that weekend in March I agree. He was unbeatable that weekend. But even the rest of that season he wasn't that guy. He just was never a guy who was going to grind out 3 months of winning mentally or physically. Plus he never came close to that peak again after that tournament.