Jump to content

goStanford18

Members
  • Content Count

    84
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by goStanford18

  1. In the last 15 years, I would personally go with McIntosh. edit: (if we're excluding Pico) I don't think anyone scored any offensive points against McIntosh in folkstyle during his Junior and Senior years. I don't know if anyone was competitive with him his senior year. He was destroying everyone from 189-215. He split matches against future teammate Ed Ruth @ 84kg Junior FS Nationals in the spring of 2010. Here's the match he won. McIntosh was still a high school junior, and Ed Ruth was months away from dominating the NCAA. Here's McIntosh manhandling Gabe Dean their senior years @ FloNationals. After his senior season ended, McIntosh bumped all the up to 215 for junior freestyle nationals and destroyed the field there. Here's him dominating a younger Adam Coon. Spoiler: he hits Coon with an arm throw and pins him in the first. I'm always surprised McIntosh didn't have a more successful college career. I wonder if he would have won a couple of national titles down at 184. He looked like a small 197lber as a true freshman. He entered NCAAs as the 3 seed as a sophomore, but placed 7th. He placed 3/2 as a junior/senior. After some more thought, he was blocked by Wright as a true freshman and by Ruth as RS sophomore. Cox and/or Snyder were in his brackets his sophomore-senior seasons. Fun fact: McIntosh is only one of two wrestlers to beat both Cox and Snyder in college. The other is Gadson. McIntosh is the only one to do it in the same season
  2. agreed. Dave Schultz is easily my #1 all-time CA guy, considering all accolades at any level. The Mount Rushmore of CA wrestling would be the Schultz Brothers, Varner, and Abas—with Neal just missing the cut. Based purely on high school accolades, CA is a lot harder to rank. For PA, I think it’s easily Kolat. I’m a big Marsteller fan, but I don’t think he had any signature wins against other blue chips his last two years in high school. He didn’t do much on the freestyle circuit after his sophomore year either. I thought a one-year older BoJo and IMar could beat him in 2013. I also think a younger Mark Hall and Anthony Valencia would’ve given him all he could handle in 2014. Chance’s best win during that time was probably an OT match against Weircoch. I think the 4 guys I mentioned above would’ve torched Weircoch. I’m pretty sure BoJo teched him a year later or so into college. Marsteller did eventually meet a younger Hall at the 2015 Junior Trial Finals and Hall destroyed him in less than 30 seconds. Spencer Lee is mentioned too for PA, but IMO his lack of size hurts him. He didn’t grow into 125 until he hit college, so he did not have any crazy wins against older wrestlers. He does hold cadet and junior world titles, but they’re all at 50kg. Frankly, his losses to DeSanto and Fix take him out of the running for me.
  3. Touché. I will admit Jimmy Carr is way before my time, and I didn’t even think to consider anyone pre-80s. FWIW, I do think Kolat is without a doubt a top 5 all-time wrestler in high school. I agree that Pico is often excluded since he stopped folk style after his freshman year. If we’re excluding him here, then I’d have to change my pick—but I don’t think I’d take any other CA guy over Kolat’s resume. What??? I literally said Seth isn’t even in my top 15 CA wrestlers despite his 1XX-1 high school record and 4 state titles. In fact, I said none of the CA 4-timers would crack my top 15 from CA. I said Pico had little to nothing to prove scholastically on the folk style scene after his freshman year. He went to the toughest national tournaments and beat nearly everyone there was to beat in his weight range. He won Ironman during the winter that featured all the top dogs at 132. He smashed McKenna at 138 in the spring, and he wrecked Retherford the following year (who was fresh off his first AA honor)—but those matches were in freestyle. I’m simply taking him over Kolat because I believe he objectively accomplished more in freestyle than Kolat did as a high schooler.
  4. Based off what they accomplished in high school only, I don’t see how Kolat really has an argument over Pico. Kolat beating a bunch of high schoolers in folk style doesn’t do it for me. CA has one of the toughest state tournaments, and Pico won it. Walsh Ironman is the toughest national tournament, and he also won that. There wasn’t much left to prove scholastically in folk style. IMO, racking up another 100 wins against a lot of guys who would never go to the D1 level or AA does nothing for his legacy. I’ll take 5 wins to none against Zain Retherford, wins over JO, Humphrey, Molinaro and a win against Safaryan over Kolat placing at Midlands and placing at WTT trials. He literally beat a world champion and a handful of NCAA champs as a high schooler. I don’t see 19-23 year old Pico taking 7 losses at the NCAA level like Kolat did (or running away from any wrestlers either), but I suppose it’s true that we’ll never know. Looks like we strongly disagree on the importance of high school folk style wins.
  5. I believe he was an 8th grader entering his freshman year. Heil was entering his senior year. Pico never won midlands (or entered), but I have a feeling he could’ve easily won it 3x from his sophomore-senior years if he wanted to. He thrashed Zain in spring/summer 2015, and everyone was avoiding Zain at 149. Pico was also runner-up at the Olympic trials. He beat Ness (Hodge winner), Oliver (2x NCAA champ), Humphrey (multiple world team member), and even took a match off Molinaro. Domestically, I don’t think you can get more prestigious than that. He was a takedown away from being the Rio rep. I also think he has the better age-group credentials (cadet Gold, 2 junior world medals) than Kolat, and he had more impressive senior-level wins. He beat 2013 world champ Safaryan as a high school Junior. internationally, he took a few losses, but I’m not sure to who. I know Yazdani and Chamizo beat him, but there were a few others too.
  6. I guess it depends on how much value you put into state championships. Personally, I don’t see how Pico gains any points for beating on high schoolers at the CA state tournament or even the Walsh Ironman. Would ~100 more wins over high schoolers really shoot him up on a list of all-timers? It’s hard for me to picture any high schooler in that 138-152 range beat him from 2013-2016 (Pico’s sophomore-senior years) or even really give him a match. Maybe a senior Jason Nolf vs. a sophomore Pico would be a good match, but I think Pico goes right through him. He handled Zain rather easily in 2014–who was already an AA, and he dominated Zain again the following year before Zain went on to go torch the NCAA for three consecutive years. Molinaro, Metcalf, Humphrey, and Stieber are the only Americans I can recall beating a high school Pico from 2014-16, and they were all already NCAA champs/world team members at that point of their careers.
  7. I believe this thread is just for HS resume. For CA: - HS: Aaron Pico - College: Stephen Abas - International: Dave Schultz
  8. Pico was runner-up at the Olympic Trials and had wins over multiple NCAA Champs. I would easily pick him over Kolat based off accomplishments in high school.
  9. I don't think any CA wrestler has gone 4 for 4 and undefeated in high school. CA has had four 4-timers: Jesse Vasquez, Seth Nevills, Justin Mejia, and Darrell Vasquez. Personally, I wouldn't put any of them in my top 15 from CA--even solely based on high school accomplishments. IMO, the CA HS GOAT has to be Aaron Pico--and I don't think it's close. He was only 42-0 and a 1x state champion, but his national/world accomplishments on the freestyle circuit probably make him the GOAT HS wrestler. IIRC, Pico was in the high school class of 2016. So before he finished high school, he was: - 2012 Walsh Ironman Champ - 2013 CA State Champ - 2013 Cadet World Gold - 2014 Junior World Silver (runner-up to Yazdani) - 2015 Junior World Bronze - 2016 Olympic Trials Finalist (runner-up to Molinaro) Some guys he beat in that time frame: Micah Jordan, Joey McKenna, Zain Retherford, Jayson Ness, Jordan Oliver, Reece Humphrey. If Pico is excluded from the discussion, then it would be really tough to pick a HS GOAT from CA. Here are some options: - Zahid Valencia (#1 in recruit in 2015) - Morgan McIntosh (#1 recruit in 2011) - Jason Welch (#1 recruit in 2008) - Stephen Abas - Eric Guerrero - Dave Schultz None of them went undefeated.
  10. I thought it was USA Wrestling's policy that Junior World medalists could try their hand at the Senior level tournament and would be allowed a special wrestle off for the Junior spot if they liked--since the two tournaments take place on the same weekend. IIRC, Daton Fix got the same treatment as McKenna just a couple years later. FWIW, I could be remembering very wrong.
  11. Seems like everyone forgets Snyder is the only guy to have beaten him in the last 8 years.
  12. I can't believe Nick Lee beat Retherford. To follow that up by torching Yianni. How did this guy ever lose in this tournament?
  13. Random thought: it would have been nice to see Logan Stieber come out of retirement like Gabe Dean and qualify through last chance. I never expected him to hang it up a couple of years before Taylor and Dake. He retired on top of the US ladder @ 65kg in 2019 just before the US Open. I would’ve very selfishly liked to see him leave his shoes on the mat ala Molinaro if he lost to one of the top guys. I bet he could still take out half the field
  14. Isn’t McKenna with Coach Slay @ UPenn’s RTC now? and Snyder’s w/ Cael at the NLWC. So he’d attract recruits to Penn State (case in point: Kerk) Ohio State is guaranteed to have an alumni be an Olympian, but their current RTC roster likely will have 0 olympians this cycle. Moore would have to beat Snyder.
  15. Moore is looking good. Don't know if he has any answers for big brother Snyder tomorrow.
  16. Kennedy is dominating Molinari. How old is she? 16? 17? Insane.
  17. Fix has about 90 seconds to storm back
  18. Fix looks like he has nothing for Arujau
  19. I'm on Peacock, and it's only showing mat 3 and 4. My guess is NBC has 1 and 2.
  20. This match really has it all. Lmao
  21. This match had been great so far. Living up to the hype. Could watch Valencia and Nickal go at it all day. both are so slick
  22. You seem to really dislike Kyle Snyder. What’s your beef with him?
×
×
  • Create New...