I completely agree with this. And even 2 years ago, they were pretty close matches.
Ultimately, I don't even think it's completely dependent on who beats who, the coaches know who they want in the lineup. Last year there were starters who were beat in the room - more than enough times to just be called a fluke, they remained starters. I would have to trust that they are looking at the big picture - which covers more than a season, for their decisions.
Although I don't always like them. And sometimes wish they would coach from my seat, I know I see it clearly. ;)