Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
CA_Wrestler

Japan playoff matches

Recommended Posts

There will be a new 50kg rep for Japan as Yuki Irie knocked off Yui Susaki(2x defending senior WC) 6-1.  Susaki beat Irie last month 6-2 at All-Japan.  This will be interesting because they are clearly the #1 and #2 in the world at 50kg.  Irie is the only person to have beaten Susaki(3 or 4 times now).  Unless some fluke happens at the World Championships, Irie is going to medal(high chance of winning) and that means that Susaki will not be or have the chance to be on the 2020 team.  I'm interested to see if the Japan Wrestling Federation is really going to keep those 2020 qualification rules.

Risako Kawai beat Kaori Icho 3-3 on criteria

Otoguro also beat Rei Higuchi in the playoff to become of the 2019 rep at 65kg.  Higuchi teched him last month.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
4 hours ago, CA_Wrestler said:

There will be a new 50kg rep for Japan as Yuki Irie knocked off Yui Susaki(2x defending senior WC) 6-1.  Susaki beat Irie last month 6-2 at All-Japan.  This will be interesting because they are clearly the #1 and #2 in the world at 50kg.  Irie is the only person to have beaten Susaki(3 or 4 times now).  Unless some fluke happens at the World Championships, Irie is going to medal(high chance of winning) and that means that Susaki will not be or have the chance to be on the 2020 team.  I'm interested to see if the Japan Wrestling Federation is really going to keep those 2020 qualification rules.

Risako Kawai beat Kaori Icho 3-3 on criteria

Otoguro also beat Rei Higuchi in the playoff to become of the 2019 rep at 65kg.  Higuchi teched him last month.

Wow, interesting to see the back and forth of those competitors.

What was the score of the Otoguro/Higuchi match?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

WOW, what’s the story with Icho?? I feel like that is the biggest story, not to take anything away from Kawai who is a hammer. 

Did she have enough time since returning to the sport to get the rust out? I really hope she doesn’t retire - I want to see her compete in the 2020 Olympics. The coaching scandal stuff will make a huge mess out of whatever process Japan puts in place (or even if they just let it be) for their Olympic team next year.

Edited by pamela

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
8 hours ago, pamela said:

WOW, what’s the story with Icho?? I feel like that is the biggest story, not to take anything away from Kawai who is a hammer. 

Did she have enough time since returning to the sport to get the rust out? I really hope she doesn’t retire - I want to see her compete in the 2020 Olympics. The coaching scandal stuff will make a huge mess out of whatever process Japan puts in place (or even if they just let it be) for their Olympic team next year.

I don't know if Icho was back long enough.  She was right there with Kawai, which is crazy after taking 2 years off and not competing.

With the way Japan put in the 2020 qualification criteria- If you're on the 2019 team and medal, that guarantees your 2020 spot, we probably won't see Icho, Susaki, Okuno and a bunch of other world champs from Japan.  This is why I'm wondering if they're going to do a playoff.  Returning medalist has a spot in the final and then the tournament winner battles the returning medalist.

It'll be interesting to see what happens by next year.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
4 hours ago, CA_Wrestler said:

I don't know if Icho was back long enough.  She was right there with Kawai, which is crazy after taking 2 years off and not competing.

With the way Japan put in the 2020 qualification criteria- If you're on the 2019 team and medal, that guarantees your 2020 spot, we probably won't see Icho, Susaki, Okuno and a bunch of other world champs from Japan.  This is why I'm wondering if they're going to do a playoff.  Returning medalist has a spot in the final and then the tournament winner battles the returning medalist.

It'll be interesting to see what happens by next year.

It will look pretty bad for Japan’s wrestling federation if there’s no wrestle-off for the Olympics, assuming Kawai (and the others) medal at Worlds, because Sakae was the reason Icho stepped away and people may speculate that he’s pulling strings behind the scenes to keep Icho locked out - even though he’s banned from the sport. 

It will also be embarrassing if Japan changes up their Olympic team selection process after the fact. 

I’m interested in seeing what Icho and the other wrestlers might do from a PR perspective. Culturally it may be out of the norm to complain publicly about the rules, so maybe they won’t say anything, but it will probably be up to the athletes, coaches, and fans to speak up if they want Japan Wrestling to open up the process. Could be a real mess.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
5 minutes ago, pamela said:

It will look pretty bad for Japan’s wrestling federation if there’s no wrestle-off for the Olympics, assuming Kawai (and the others) medal at Worlds, because Sakae was the reason Icho stepped away and people may speculate that he’s pulling strings behind the scenes to keep Icho locked out - even though he’s banned from the sport. 

It will also be embarrassing if Japan changes up their Olympic team selection process after the fact. 

I’m interested in seeing what Icho and the other wrestlers might do from a PR perspective. Culturally it may be out of the norm to complain publicly about the rules, so maybe they won’t say anything, but it will probably be up to the athletes, coaches, and fans to speak up if they want Japan Wrestling to open up the process. Could be a real mess.

Yeah, it definitely could be a really bad mess.  Especially because what are the 2nd place Japan WTT supposed to do this year and next?  If they're not able to compete for the World championships this year and try to qualify for the 2020 Olympics, that's basically almost a year of competing for nothing besides staying sharp and being on the national team.  I'm sure UWW will probably hold another one of those World Championships that didn't have Olympic weights, but the top wrestlers aren't there for the most part.

Imagine if for some reason Pat Downey medaled this year at 86, Burroughs medals(I'm expecting him to win, Cox medals(I'm expecting him to win)  and Snyder medals(I'm expecting him to win) , then DT would be off the team.  Dake would be also be off the team with no chance to compete at a trial.  That would be insane.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Susaki/Irie is an interesting selection dilemma:

You have Susaki who is undefeated internationally, 2x world champ (aged 18 and 19) and crushed the field last time out, looks all set to be the star & 'face' of the team for your home Olympics. If I was coach I'd be completely confident of Susaki winning gold in 2020.

...but then there is Irie who must be a bad/awkward match for Susaki as they trade wins in domestic tournaments with Irie coming out on top slightly more often. However Irie has fallen short several times at the global level and has no world titles yet. If I was coach I would not be completely confident of Irie winning gold in 2020.
But, she just won the selection battle again & your own rules say if she even gets a Bronze at worlds this year then she goes to Tokyo... what a headache. ;)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
4 hours ago, ufo said:

Susaki/Irie is an interesting selection dilemma:

You have Susaki who is undefeated internationally, 2x world champ (aged 18 and 19) and crushed the field last time out, looks all set to be the star & 'face' of the team for your home Olympics. If I was coach I'd be completely confident of Susaki winning gold in 2020.

...but then there is Irie who must be a bad/awkward match for Susaki as they trade wins in domestic tournaments with Irie coming out on top slightly more often. However Irie has fallen short several times at the global level and has no world titles yet. If I was coach I would not be completely confident of Irie winning gold in 2020.
But, she just won the selection battle again & your own rules say if she even gets a Bronze at worlds this year then she goes to Tokyo... what a headache. ;)

I'd definitely be more confident with Susaki winning gold in 2020.  Irie is just a bad matchup for Susaki in matches.  Doesn't help that Susaki's elbow isn't 100% from when she dislocated it in practice last year.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 7/7/2019 at 10:58 AM, pamela said:

It will look pretty bad for Japan’s wrestling federation if there’s no wrestle-off for the Olympics, assuming Kawai (and the others) medal at Worlds, because Sakae was the reason Icho stepped away and people may speculate that he’s pulling strings behind the scenes to keep Icho locked out - even though he’s banned from the sport. 

It will also be embarrassing if Japan changes up their Olympic team selection process after the fact. 

I’m interested in seeing what Icho and the other wrestlers might do from a PR perspective. Culturally it may be out of the norm to complain publicly about the rules, so maybe they won’t say anything, but it will probably be up to the athletes, coaches, and fans to speak up if they want Japan Wrestling to open up the process. Could be a real mess.

Why would it look bad if they use the criteria they setup in advance and the wrestler who won is rewarded for winning.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, boconnell said:

Why would it look bad if they use the criteria they setup in advance and the wrestler who won is rewarded for winning.

Aside from being a faulty process that puts world caliber talent out of competition for 2 years in a row (see @CA_Wrestler‘s post above), it will look bad because Icho couldn’t compete during the coaching abuse scandal and because Sakae still has power and clout politically even though he is no longer affiliated with Japan Wrestling, and it’ll reek of stonewalling Icho, which is something he actually has a history of doing.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, pamela said:

Aside from being a faulty process that puts world caliber talent out of competition for 2 years in a row (see @CA_Wrestler‘s post above), it will look bad because Icho couldn’t compete during the coaching abuse scandal and because Sakae still has power and clout politically even though he is no longer affiliated with Japan Wrestling, and it’ll reek of stonewalling Icho, which is something he actually has a history of doing.

The match was wrestled and nobody is questioning the outcome.  There may have been stonewalling in the past but there is none here.  Just a great wrestler getting beat by another great wrestler.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, boconnell said:

The match was wrestled and nobody is questioning the outcome.  There may have been stonewalling in the past but there is none here.  Just a great wrestler getting beat by another great wrestler.

Look upthread a bit, Icho and Kawai wrestled but Icho was away from the sport during the coaching scandal with the Japan Wrestling and many, including Icho believe she didn't have enough time to train. And Sakae literally had her blocked from using certain training facilities. That's why it's speculated that he may still have his hands in this current situation. I just don't think it's a straightforward situation as "x beat y, end of story".

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
Sign in to follow this  

×
×
  • Create New...